Is it possible for a Force-user to control water? I know Kit Fisto could create pockets of air underwater with the Force, but I’m talking something more extreme—could a Jedi, for instance, change the direction of a river’s flow, or even stop it altogether? Could they even part the river in two and walk through it moses-style? (Basically can Jedi waterbend, is what I’m asking :D)

Yes, it is possible for a Jedi to manipuate water. This power would probably fall under the Force ability Alter Environment. I cannot recall personally reading about a Jedi controlling water in a drastic way, so I wouldn’t be able to describe how it could work or what it might feel like, but I do know of examples similar to those you gave, such as creating whirlpools and large waves.

~ Jacen

Say a force user of slightly above average strength was trying to force-push a massive asteroid into another ship, while out in space themselves. Would it be easy to do, given the lack of gravity and air resistance in space? Or would it take a lot of effort still?

Theoretically, it would be very very difficult and would require the Jedi’s ship to be flying at speed towards the asteroid, even taking into account the extra strength given by the Force. Because the asteroid is so much more massive than the Jedi and their ship, any force applied to the asteroid by the Jedi would cause the ship to move away from the asteroid much faster than the asteroid away from the ship. Because of the lack of any friction, there’s nothing to oppose the ship’s unwanted movement. However, the Force doesn’t seem to exactly follow the laws of physics, and in fact behaves quite inconsistently even within the series.

I won’t get into a full analysis of how the Force works, but from examples it seems that the “equal and opposite reaction” rule still applies. That means, to make that asteroid move, your Jedi’s ship will have to be moving towards the asteroid. Obviously there are nuances that would make moving an asteroid from inside a ship a physically difficult feat (e.g., the force pushing back on the Jedi should crush them into their seat because the ship cannot move backwards), but since things like that are often ignored in canon I would say you shouldn’t worry about it.

To answer your actual question: moving a large object in space would be easier (though more complicated) than moving it in a gravity well, but it would still take a lot of effort because of the mass of the object. Exactly how much effort is up to you, and depends on exactly how massive the asteroid is as well as (judging from canon) how strong your Jedi is in telekinesis.

I know some of that might be a bit confusing, so feel free to send another ask or a message if you’d like clarification on anything. I hope it helps!

~ Jacen

Hello. Are jedi allowed to have any expensive possessions? Like one or two if they wish to own? Would it be out of line if I say they own bit expensive material tunic or robes to wear for special occasions? I searched wookieepedia, while it says there are no restrictions on how they choose to customize their attire they usually keep it in line with their ideals, and one Jedi Lord did have robes with gems. Can I say it depends on an individual’s taste and what they wish to own? Thanks in advance.

As with most things regarding what Jedi are and aren’t allowed to do, there is wiggle room here. Generally, Jedi were forbidden from owning more than a few essential things. Many interpretations of the Jedi Code speak of resisting materialism; this, along with the fact that Jedi were often sent on long missions with little notice, meant it was rare for a Jedi to own more possessions than they could carry with them. It was conventional for their robes to be made of material that was warm and comfortable but not extravagant, as they believed it helped them resist distractions and become closer to the Force. That said, there were plenty of instances where Jedi customized their outfit, often to show a connection to their home planet or heritage. If a Jedi Master or Knight chose to wear more comfortable or ornate robes, it probably would have been allowed.

This is all era-dependant of course, as interpretations of the Code varied quite a bit over time, and Jedi were afforded more freedom in some times than others. In the New Jedi Order, for instance, they had a lot more choice over their outfit than before Order 66. Up to a limit, it did depend largely on the individual’s taste, as well as the kinds of missions or jobs they often did. If your character(s) wanted to wear more expensive robes, they probably wouldn’t have an issue.

Hope that helps!

~ Jacen

Disregarding full obliteration by the Death Star/Starkiller base, are there any examples of worlds in the galaxy “ending”? Y’know, just the surface of the world being completely destroyed by war, natural disasters, disease, famine, etc.—something that could give the planet a post-apocalyptic landscape?

The most drastic example that comes to mind is the planet Duro. During the Clone Wars it was bombarded from orbit by the Separatists, releasing radioactive chemicals from its factories and turning it into an uninhabitable wasteland. Humbarine was also destroyed by the Separatists in an orbital bombardment.

Coruscant could also be considered an example, as the lower levels definitely had a post-apocalyptic appearance, and the lowest ones were completely uninhabitable due to filth and pollution and the monsters that lived there.

Melida/Daan was a planet whose cities were devastated by war, but outside the cities there was still vegetation and a natural landscape.

Kamino’s surface was completely covered by flooding, destroying the infrastructure and forcing the Kaminoans to build cities above the water. This was the cause of the endless storms the planet became known for.

The entire population of Candoria and its colony worlds was eradicated by the Blue Shadow Virus in 42 BBY, though we don’t know how this affected the actual planet itself.

There are also several worlds that became so heavily industrialized that they took on a post-apocalyptic appearance. Fondor and Eriadu are examples of this.

Hope that helps!

~ Jacen

EDIT: Thank you @pomrania for reminding me about Mandalore! It completely slipped my mind. Large parts of its surface were destroyed by the Mandalorian Excision.

What is the path for a padawan to become a Jedi Knight? Is it age related? Their master’s approval? There a test, yes? What does it look like? And what happens if they fail it? Are there any rituals or ceremonies? Cutting of the braid?

For a Padawan to become a Knight, they had to pass the Trials of Knighthood. These tests were administered by the High Council, to Padawans they believed to be ready. While age did not directly play a part in the Council’s decision to have someone take the tests, most Padawans were knighted in their twenties. The Master’s approval was not required, though I believe that they could recommend that their Padawan be tested.

During the Trials of Knighthood, a Padawan had to pass five trials: the Trials of Skill, Courage, Spirit, Flesh, and Insight. If deemed appropriate, the Council may have also substituted tests or waived them if the Padawan had shown the same qualities through their actions. For instance, both Anakin and Obi-Wan became Knights without participating in formal trials.

For the Trial of Skill, one must face a three-part assessment consisting of physical, mental, and combat challenges. The physical challenges were usually tests of strength, endurance, climbing, jumping and the like. The mental challenges were tests of levitation, another endurance test, duress and reflection. For the combat challenges, Padawans completed tests of conflict, duelling, and of the calm mind, and were required to face some sort of adversary. The individual or individuals they face would vary a lot, from holograms to droids to other students, or even the Temple Battlemaster or Grand Master. Some students may fight many opponents using many different weapons or altering the appearance of the chamber or their perception. While the tests largely consisted of physical feats, the Battlemaster looked more for the ability of a Padawan to use discipline and focus to avoid distraction. Anakin completed this trial when he defeated Asajj Ventress in combat.

Less is known about the Trial of Courage. In order for the test to work, the student must not know beforehand what they will face. Before the Golden Age of the Republic, courage on the battlefield or facing a Sith was considered a good way to pass the trial, but later tests were largely simulated. The Council could also send a student on a real mission; these missions had the potential to be deadly, which is why only students who are ready may participate in the Trials. When Obi-Wan defeated Darth Maul on Naboo, the Council considered that his Trial of Courage.

The Trial of the Spirit was a test of self-discovery. A Padawan entered a deep meditative trance and confronted their deepest fears and the darkness within themselves. Such deep meditation could be very dangerous, so a Master was always present to help guide the student back to the present. Unlike other tests, the High Council did not dictate what would happen and the student would have to decide what to do on their journey. This test had the potential to be highly traumatising, and some students would wake from a failed test inconsolable.

The Trial of the Flesh was considered the hardest test of the five, and it involved the Padawan experiencing great physical pain, loss, or hardship. In the earlier days of the Republic, the students were subjected to bursts of electricity applied directly to the skin, but this practice was abandoned. During the New Sith Wars, battle scars and lost limbs were often accepted as a way to pass the test. It was not uncommon for a Padawan to pass the Trials of the Flesh, Skill and Courage at the same time by defeating a Sith on the battlefield. Later, the separation of the Master-Padawan pair as the Padawan became a Knight was considered a hardship enough to pass the test, but during the Clone Wars it was once again common to pass through physical injury and loss.

The Trial of Insight was a test that required the Padawan to use the Force to see through deception. To pass, they were forbidden to study any possible challenges in the Archives, as they had to complete it themselves. The Trial sometimes took the form of riddles and puzzles, such as being required to solve the High Riddles of Dwartii. Other known scenarios are having to find one grain of sand among a field of rocks, or being faced with an army of holograms and forced to see through the illusion.

If a Padawan passed all these tests in one way or another, their Master would then prepare them for the Knighting Ceremony. If they failed, they had the opportunity to take them again until they passed. Before the ceremony, the student would meditate in the preparation room in the Tranquility Spire for a whole day. The next day, they would go up to the next level of the Tower, called the Hall of Knighthood. There, they would kneel in front of the Grand Master, the members of the High Council (if the High Council was unavailable, members of the other two Councils would step in), and other Jedi who were influential in the Padawan’s journey. The present Masters would ignite their lightsabers in a circle around the apprentice, and the Grand Master would lower their lightsaber to just above each of the student’s shoulders before severing their braid. The new Knight would then take their braid and leave the Hall in silence.

During Kanan’s knighting during a vision in the Lothal Jedi Temple, the words said were, “By the right of the Council, by the will of the Force, Kanan Jarrus, you may rise.” This may have also been said during more orthodox ceremonies, or another similar phrase.

Hopefully that’s helpful, and good luck!

~ Jacen

How well do you think a lightsaber could cauterize a pre-existing wound? It wouldn’t be the most efficient or safe, and you could easily make it worse, but if someone’s bleeding to death, do you think it would work in a pinch?

I think it could work just fine in an emergency, as long as the wound wasn’t too deep. There is confusion over whether a lightsaber always cauterizes as it’s cutting (canon suggests a lightsaber wound should bleed and Legends suggests the opposite), but using it purposefully as a heat source over a few seconds or so would most likely work. It also shouldn’t be too dangerous, if the one using it has a steady hand, because there should be no need to cut deeper. Holding the blade so it just touches the wound should be enough. You may also want to send an ask to @scriptmedic when their ask box opens again, to find out whether cauterization is the right way to go in your scenario.

~ Jacen

Were there any Hutts throughout SW’s history (preferably around the Rise of the Empire/Rebellion eras) who didn’t adhere to the typical “fat, lazy crime boss” stereotype? Like, were there any actually good, decent Hutts?

I know of one Hutt who was a highly respected scientist and one who was a Jedi, but the former lived long before the Rise of the Empire era and the latter had already turned to the dark side by that time. There were a couple others who were considered legitimate businessmen, but again none of them lived in that time. It is certainly possible that there were Hutts during the Rise of the Empire/Rebellion eras that were upstanding citizens, but if you were hoping for specific examples I think you may be out of luck.

~ Jacen

Do you know who Devaron’s governor was during the Imperial era or, if none was ever shown, who the governor of the Colonies region was during that time?

Devaron was not, to my knowledge, appointed a governor, because it supported the Empire and had its own autonomous government and military. The president of Devaron through the Clone Wars and as the Empire was founded was Aven’sai’Ulrahk, though it is not clear how long she remained in office under the Empire.

As well, Devaron was under the authority of the Grand Moff of the Corellian Oversector. This position was held by Fliry Vorru in the last days of the Republic and under the New Order, until he was succeeded by Naomi Dargon sometime after 7 BBY.

Hope that helps!

~ Jacen

Hi, first of all: awesome blog!! For a story I write I would need a battle or subjugation of a planet during the Empire era before the first Death Star was complete, which the rebellion would consider a war crime and the empire themselves celebrated as a big victory. Is there something that ticks the boxes? Preferably nothing which directly involved Vader. TIA

There are a couple issues here. One, that we don’t know exactly when the Death Star was built. We know it was first used in 0 BBY, and that planning for it began as far back as before the Clone Wars, but not exactly when it was built. It can be inferred from the events of Rogue One that construction probably began roughly around 13 BBY (though the timelines are very conflicting).

The other issue is that before ~5 BBY, there wasn’t much of a Rebellion. There were organized cells, several with higher management such as Bail Organa, but they were very separate and didn’t so much work in tandem as do whatever they felt would deal the biggest blow to the Empire.

Basically, there would be no Rebellion to see this event as a war crime, if the event were to occur before the construction of the Death Star. However, there’s still the leaders of the early rebellion: the Delegation of 2000, namely Bail Organa and Mon Mothma.

If that’s not a huge issue to you, there are some events that could work:

The Ghorman Massacre (18 BBY) — Tarkin landed his ship in the middle of a protest, which led the Delegation of 2000 to begin planning organized rebellion.

The Battle of Naboo (18 BBY) — Naboo was placed under Imperial rule after Queen Apailana and her Jedi protectors were killed.

The Battle of Acherin (18 BBY) — The planet of Acherin is bombarded from orbit because of the presence of Separatist forces, even after their surrender.

The Antar Atrocity (canon, 18 BBY) — A series of massacres, executions and unlawful arrests carried out by Tarkin on Antar IV as punishment for their involvement with the Separatists.

They all happen very early in the Empire’s rule, due to the period of unrest. After this time period, up to the destruction of Jedha’s Holy City, there are very few serious incidents to be noted. I’m not sure any of these incidents could be considered a significant victory for the Empire, but that depends on your context.

I hope this helps!

~ Jacen

I know there are regulations about the height of X-Wing pilots. Joph Seastriker is described as being just barely tall enough, Piggy is just barely short enough. Do we know the actual heights that someone has to be within?

Unfortunately, I don’t think we do. From Piggy’s height we can infer that the maximum is probably around 190-200 centimeters, but Joph’s height is never given. However, I did a quick search regarding Air Force height requirements and fighter jets, and I found that the size of a fighter jet seems to be roughly comparable to the size of an X-wing. Given that, and the fact that the maximum height of a fighter pilot is about 196 cm (just above Piggy’s height), the minimum height an X-wing pilot can be is probably around 160-165 cm (as the minimum height of a fighter pilot is 163 cm).

It’s not exactly canon, but I hope this gives you something to go off of!

~ Jacen